On October 29, a federal judge made its final ruling in Massachusetts et al. v. Oz et al. The case involved a coalition of states arguing the new Medicaid work and community requirements Interim Final Rule (IFR) will make it harder for vulnerable Americans to maintain coverage that they should otherwise qualify for.
The judge ruled in favor of the states and state leaders (the Plaintiff States) in two major ways:
- Eliminating the “significant impairment” test: The Medicaid Interim Final Rule (IFR) attempted to redefine “medically frail” as conditions “significantly impairs the individual’s ability to comply with the community engagement requirements. The judge ruled this is unlawful and cannot be enforced.
- Allowing six months of non-enforcement: The judge ruled the Plaintiff States could not be punished for any error or delays in implementing the IFR for six months.
The ruling is good news for individuals with special health care needs and complex medical conditions since it removes the need to provide additional paperwork to prove their medical conditions. The ruling will also provide states additional time to ensure individuals who need coverage do not lose it.
States and state leaders leading the lawsuit included:
- Commonwealth of Massachusetts
- State of California
- State of New Jersey
- State of Arizona
- State of Colorado
- State of Connecticut
- State of Delaware
- District of Columbia
- State of Hawaii
- State of Illinois
- Andy Beshear in his role as Governor of Kentucky
- State of Maine
- State of Maryland
- State of Michigan
- State of Minnesota
- State of New Mexico
- State of New York
- State of Nevada
- State of North Carolina
- State of Oregon
- Josh Shapiro in his role as Governor of Pennsylvania
- State of Rhode Island
- State of Vermont
- Commonwealth of Virginia
- State of Washington
- State of Wisconsin
Individuals and advocates should work with their states to ensure that individuals with special health care needs, disabilities, and medical complexities, especially children do not lose much-needed health coverage.
















